St. Augustine’s Nights of Lights is one of the most enchanting holiday displays in the country, transforming the historic city into a sparkling wonderland. Millions of tiny lights illuminate the cobblestone streets, waterfront, and centuries-old architecture, creating an unforgettable experience for visitors of all ages. After soaking up the magic of the lights, nothing completes the evening quite like a delicious meal at one of the city’s standout restaurants. From elegant fine dining to cozy, casual eateries, St. Augustine offers an array of dining options that perfectly complement the holiday spirit. Here’s your guide to the best places to eat while exploring this festive tradition.

Fine Dining

Columbia Restaurant

Fresh fish topped with a savory tomato, caper, and mushroom sauce, served with yellow rice and mixed vegetables at Columbia Restaurant in St. Augustine.

A staple of St. Augustine’s dining scene, Columbia Restaurant combines the flavors of Spanish and Cuban cuisine in a beautiful, historic setting on St. George Street. This iconic restaurant has been serving up its famous 1905 Salad and signature dishes like Paella for over a century, offering a taste of Spain right in the heart of St. Augustine. During the holiday season, the warm lighting and festive décor add to the ambiance, making it an ideal spot to savor a meal and a pitcher of sangria after an evening of holiday lights.

Raintree Restaurant

Gourmet burger served with a side of fries and a glass of beer at Raintree Restaurant, set on a bar counter with a selection of spirits in the background.

Photo provided by SAIRA Facebook page

Set in a restored Victorian home with fireplaces, lush decor, and a romantic atmosphere, Raintree Restaurant is perfect for a special night out. Known for its rich menu of premium steaks, fresh seafood, and European-inspired dishes, Raintree also offers an extensive wine list to complement your meal. The experience here is upscale yet inviting, making it ideal for couples or groups celebrating the season.

The Reef Restaurant

Outdoor view of The Reef Restaurant with a sunset in the background.

Image Credit:https://www.facebook.com/TheReefRestaurant/

With panoramic ocean views, The Reef provides a memorable dining experience that feels both indulgent and scenic. Located on the beach, this upscale seafood restaurant is known for dishes like lobster tail, scallops, and filet mignon. Watch the waves as you dine on carefully crafted plates, making it a great spot for a sophisticated evening following the dazzling lights downtown.

Casual Dining

The Floridian

Outdoor patio seating at the Floridian restaurant in St. Augustine.

The Floridian is an excellent choice if you’re looking for fresh, locally sourced Southern cuisine with a modern twist. This cozy restaurant serves up flavorful dishes such as shrimp and grits, fried green tomatoes, and craft cocktails. With a cozy, welcoming interior and an eclectic vibe, it’s the perfect place to unwind and enjoy some local flavors in a relaxed setting.

Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille

People eating outside under twinkling lights and trees at Harry's Seafood Bar and Grille in St. Augustine.

Image Credit: https://hookedonharrys.com/location/st-augustine/

Located in the heart of the light display on the bayfront, Harry’s offers a vibrant mix of New Orleans-inspired flavors and seafood favorites. The courtyard seating under the stars and the festive decorations create a cheerful atmosphere that’s perfect for the holiday season. Try their jambalaya, shrimp scampi, or crawfish étouffée paired with a refreshing cocktail to celebrate the season with some Cajun flair.

Meehan’s Irish Pub

Exterior view of Meehan's Irish Pub decorated with festive lights, featuring an inviting upper balcony and a warm atmosphere in St. Augustine.

Image from Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House’s Facebook.

For those looking for a lively atmosphere, Meehan’s offers traditional Irish fare with a coastal twist. Enjoy classic pub favorites like fish and chips, hearty stews, and a pint of Guinness. From fish and chips to rich stews, the menu is packed with Irish-inspired favorites that are sure to bring warmth and comfort to your holiday experience.

Gypsy Cab Company

Exterior of Gypsy Cab Co. restaurant with sign reading 'urban cuisine' and a blue 'OPEN' sign, located in St. Augustine.

Image courtesy of https://www.instagram.com/gypsycab_sta/

Known for its “urban cuisine,” Gypsy Cab Company serves a mix of Italian, Cajun, and Mediterranean-inspired dished in a casual yet eclectic setting. Their menu is packed with flavorful options, from seafood to pasta, making it a great spot for a relaxed dinner with friends or family.

Namaste Indian Tandoori Food

Menu cover for Namaste Indian Tandoori Food in St. Augustine, featuring a red background, praying hands symbol, and decorative floral accents.

Image from Namaste Indian Tandoori Food

 

If you’re looking to introduce the family to something different, Namaste India Tandoori Food offers a flavorful and diverse menu of Indian cuisine. With its warm and welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant serves traditional dishes like chicken tikka masala and tandoori naan, perfect for sharing. Namaste Indian Tandoori Food is a wonderful choice if you’re craving bold spices and unique flavors, making it both memorable and distinct from the usual holiday fare.

Conclusion

With so many exceptional dining options, St. Augustine becomes even more magical during Nights of Lights. Whether you’re seeking an elegant evening with fine cuisine, a lively pub atmosphere, or a cozy spot to share comfort food with loved ones, the city’s diverse restaurant scene has something for everyone. As you wander through the twinkling lights and festive streets, take the time to savor the local flavors and ambiance that make dining here truly special. Enjoy the lights, the flavors, and the memories – a perfect way to celebrate the season in the nation’s oldest city.